Tudor was founded by Rolex in 1926 to offer "a watch with Rolex appearance" at a more accessible price. Nearly a century later, both brands have evolved—Tudor now makes its own in-house movements and has earned respect independent of its parent. But how do they really compare?
Quick Overview
Tudor
- Entry Price: ~$2,400
- Popular Model: Black Bay 58 ($3,975)
- Movement: In-house since 2015
- Availability: Generally available
- Grey Market: Minimal discounts
Rolex
- Entry Price: ~$6,150
- Popular Model: Submariner ($9,100)
- Movement: Always in-house
- Availability: Waitlists common
- Secondary Market: Often above retail
The Family Connection
Tudor and Rolex share more than corporate parentage. Tudor watches are manufactured in Rolex facilities, use Rolex-quality steel, and benefit from Rolex's quality control standards. The brands share cases, crystals, and bracelets on some models—though Rolex's finishing is generally more refined.
What Tudor doesn't share: Rolex's crown logo (Tudor has its shield), Rolex movements, and Rolex's stratospheric pricing. Tudor has carved its own identity—"Born to Dare" versus Rolex's pursuit of perfection.
Movement Comparison
| Feature | Tudor MT56xx | Rolex 32xx |
|---|---|---|
| Type | In-house automatic | In-house automatic |
| Power Reserve | 70 hours | 70 hours |
| Frequency | 28,800 vph | 28,800 vph |
| Accuracy | COSC (-4/+6 sec/day) | Superlative (-2/+2) |
| Finishing | Good | Excellent |
| Silicon Parts | Yes (hairspring) | Yes (Parachrom) |
Tudor's in-house movements (introduced 2015) have closed much of the gap with Rolex. Both offer 70-hour power reserve; both use silicon hairsprings for antimagnetic resistance. The difference is refinement—Rolex's finishing and accuracy standards are higher, but Tudor's movements are more than adequate for daily use.
Winner: Rolex for refinement; Tudor for value-per-specification
Build Quality & Materials
Case & Crystal
Both brands use 904L stainless steel (Rolex's proprietary alloy, more corrosion-resistant and polishable than standard 316L). Sapphire crystals are standard on both. Rolex cases receive more extensive hand-finishing, but Tudor's are excellent by any objective standard.
Bracelets
This is where differences become noticeable. Rolex bracelets feature Glidelock (tool-free adjustment), Easylink (5mm comfort extension), and ceramic inserts on sport models. Tudor bracelets are excellent but lack these micro-adjustment features. Tudor compensates with fabric straps unavailable from Rolex.
Winner: Rolex for bracelet innovation; tie for case quality
Model-by-Model Comparison
Dive Watches
| Model | Tudor Black Bay 58 | Rolex Submariner |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $3,975 | $9,100 |
| Case Size | 39mm | 41mm |
| Water Resistance | 200m | 300m |
| Power Reserve | 70 hours | 70 hours |
| Secondary Value | 70-80% retention | 100%+ retention |
GMT Watches
| Model | Tudor Black Bay GMT | Rolex GMT-Master II |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $4,075 | $10,700+ |
| Case Size | 41mm | 40mm |
| Movement | MT5652 (in-house) | 3285 (in-house) |
| Bezel | Aluminum | Ceramic (Cerachrom) |
| Availability | Generally available | Multi-year waitlist |
💰 The Price Reality
A Tudor Black Bay 58 at $3,975 delivers 90% of the Submariner experience at 44% of the price. The Submariner has better water resistance, ceramic bezel, and superior value retention—but you probably can't buy one at retail anyway. Tudor offers Rolex DNA you can actually purchase.
Value Retention
Tudor
Tudor watches retain 70-80% of retail value, which is excellent for the price range. Limited editions (like the Black Bay 58 Navy Blue) can appreciate. Tudor's steady demand and limited grey market discounts indicate strong brand health.
Rolex
Most Rolex sport models trade at or above retail on the secondary market. A Submariner bought at retail ($9,100) can be sold immediately for $12,000+. This "investment" quality makes Rolex purchases feel lower-risk—if you can acquire at retail.
Winner: Rolex — but Tudor's retention is impressive for its segment
Who Should Buy Tudor?
- You want Rolex quality without Rolex pricing
- You prefer vintage-inspired aesthetics (snowflake hands, gilt dials)
- You want a watch you can actually buy without waitlists
- You appreciate fabric/NATO strap options
- You value in-house movements but not at Rolex premium
- You want a "daily wearer" without daily anxiety
Who Should Buy Rolex?
- Brand prestige and recognition matter to you
- You have authorized dealer access or secondary market budget
- Investment potential and value retention are priorities
- You want the highest refinement and finishing
- You prefer ceramic bezels and micro-adjust bracelets
- You're buying a lifetime or heirloom piece
The Verdict by Category
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Value | Tudor (significantly) |
| Movement Quality | Rolex (marginally) |
| Finishing | Rolex |
| Availability | Tudor |
| Investment Potential | Rolex |
| Bracelet Features | Rolex |
| Strap Options | Tudor |
| Status/Recognition | Rolex |
Final Verdict
Buy Tudor if you want exceptional quality at reasonable prices. The Black Bay line offers in-house movements, COSC certification, and Rolex-adjacent build quality at 40-50% of Rolex pricing. You get 90% of the experience for half the money—and you can actually buy one.
Buy Rolex if budget allows and you have dealer access. The premium buys superior finishing, better bracelets, ceramic bezels, and investment-grade value retention. Rolex is aspirational for a reason—but so is being able to walk into a store and buy the watch you want.
Tudor is the smart money choice. Rolex is the dream. Both are excellent.
View Current Deals